What critical poetry did the young mother asma bint marwan. Jun 09, 2015 pamela geller, asma bint marwan, and america. Asm a, daughter of marwa n was a female arab poet who lived in medina in 7thcentury arabia. Prophet muhammed, asma bint marwan, hadith literature. The story of the killing of asma bint marwaan is false islam. As for the report about the slaying of asma bint marwaan that is propagated by these liars, it is a fabricated report. Nov, 2015 from bilal to sumayya, the history of islam is replete with sacrifices rendered by the companions of the prophet may allahs peace and blessings be upon him. The matter of fact is, history tells that abu afak was a very naughty man. The vulgar christian missionary using the pseudonym silas has accused prophet muhammad p of being responsible for the killing of abu afak and the death of asma bint marwan.
The story of the killing of asma bint marwan is mentioned by ibn sad in kitab attabaqat alkabir 3 and by the author of kinzulummal under number 441 who. Simply criticizing muhammad justified the death penalty, and since that time nothing. Ibn sad was born in 784 ce, some 152 years after the death of the prophet. According to the various tellings, muhammad ordered the assassination of a woman who wrote poetry criticizing his killing of another poet, abu afak. Ibn adiyy mentions this incident in his book alkamal on the. See the story as reported in the books of campaigns, such as of ibn ishaq. For 78 days, i was glued to your book, absorbing so much information that i did not know existed. Bint marwa n was known for ridiculing the people of medina for obeying a chief not of their own kind. It is alleged that asma bint marwan was assassinated by prophet mohammad p because she insulted and wrote poetry against him. There are no reports of ibn ishaqs book being burnt or its editors or printers being killed. Guillaumes translation contains all the authentic material but theres something sobering about reading it in the original language, as arabs have done for 1200 years. Five of his children, including his eldest son alasbagh, were bore by slave women. Alkhansa, alifa rifaat, samira bellil, asma bint marwan, riverbend blogger, gisele halimi, assia djebar, hanan alshaykh, tamara chalabi, fatima gallaire, leila abouzeid, nadia chafik. Jan 28, 20 1 asma bint marwan january 624 kill asma bint marwan for opposing muhammad with poetry and for provoking others to attack him.
The story of bint marwan and her death appears in the works of ibn ishaq and ibn sad. Thank you so much for your book islamic jihad and showing me the big picture. From here to coocoocachoo the search for yaser abdel said. He r father, abu bakr, was a close friend of the prophet and the first caliph after his death. Islamic history and biography biography of the prophet the story of the killing of asma bint marwaan is false. Jay smith caught using a forgery asma bint marwan fao. The story has been reported by some biographers on the prophets life, who collected stories without veri. It is alleged that asma bint marwan was assassinated by prophet mohammad p. The implications of these charges are that he p stiffles criticism by murdering his opponents. Asma was a woman of great nobility, wisdom and patience.
Ibn sad was born in the year 168ah784ce 3 and died in 230ah845ce. So, given the the example muhammad set here, does it really surprise anyone when muslims around the world violently riot every time muhammad is insulted or mocked. Wear socks and make life easy by asma bint shameem. In yathrib medina, muhammad had a number of people killed. Allah, may he be exalted, has told us in his holy book that he only. And we have to offer them daily no matter what our circumstances. In his displeasure towards her, muhammad asked his followers to murder her as well. The five daily prayers are the most important thing in a muslims life. Dec 14, 2012 the second source that mentions the story of asma bint marwan is ibn sads tabaqat. The first story i read was the raid of umayr bin uday alkhatmi to kill asma bint marwan. Abu afak was reputed to be over one hundred years old, and had dared to criticize in. From a third wife, layla bint suhayl, he had his daughter umm albanin. You have crisply covered so much in your book and quoted historical references extensively. From here to coocoocachoo the search for yaser abdel said book 6 kindle edition by schulz, denis.
May 02, 2010 tidfthe killing of asma bint marawanwafa sultan. The story of asma bint marwan and her death appears in the works of both ibn ishaq and ibn sad. It was narrated by alqadaai in musnad ashshihaab 856, alkhateeb in attareekh 99, ibn asaakir in his tareekh 51244, and ibn umar alharbi in his fawaaid 50. Marwan was killed after critcizing the murder of the old man abu afak who in his turn had been killed for criticizing muhammad. Bint marwan was known for having ridiculed the people of medina for obeying a chief not. Asma was the wife of yazid ibn zayd ibn hisn alkhatmi. Ibn sad project gutenberg selfpublishing ebooks read. Asma bint marwan wrote a poem against muhammad sallallahu alaihi. Dec 05, 2012 it was narrated by alwaaqidi in almaghaazi p. According to the reports, her family viewed muhammad and his followers as unwelcome interlopers in medina. The second source that mentions the story of asma bint marwan is ibn sads tabaqat.
Apr 04, 2015 it was narrated by alwaaqidi in almaghaazi p. Prophet muhammadsaw has been accused of ordering the killing of asma bint marwan after she had insulted himsaw through her poetry. Her halfsister, aaishah, was a wife of the prophet and one of the ummahaat almumineen mothers of the faithful. Asmaa bint abu bakr belonged to a distinguished muslim family. Asma bint marwan blames islam and the muslims which is quite. Bint marwan was known for having ridiculed the people of medina for obeying a. Asma bint marwan did not travel to mecca to lampoon mohammed. Alim provides quran translations and the opportunity to learn quran, hadith, and islamic history. Two of the individuals who were murdered at the orders of muhammad were a 120yearold jewish man named abu afak, and a jewish poetess named asma bint marwan.
The story of the killing of asma bint marwan is mentioned by ibn sad in kitab attabaqat alkabir3 and by the author of kinzulummal under number 441 who attributes it to ibn sad, ibn adiyy and ibn asaker. Abdullah ibn alhaarith told me, from his father, that asma bint marwaan, from banu umayyah ibn zayd, was married to yazeed ibn zayd ibn hisn alkhatmi. She might not have even heard of him before he took shelter in her city. Some hard truth of islamic history about bano umaya by syed riaz hussain shah sb. Companion of the prophet asmaa bint abu bakr in islamic history. T he vulgar christian missionary using the pseudonym silas has accused prophet muhammad p of being responsible for the killing of abu afak and the death of asma bint marwan. Is there any account of her life after her conversion to islam. It is a fake story, forged in order to degrade and vilify the prophet of islam as a barbaric man. The story of asma bint marwan and her death appears in the works of both ibn. Ibn sads kitab altabaqat alkabir describes the death of asma bint marwan. Jun 02, 2017 it is alleged that asma bint marwan was assassinated by prophet mohammad peace be upon him because she insulted and wrote poetry against him. The distance between jeddah and abyssinia is limited to that of the width of the red sea, which is not very difficult for a journey.
One narration makes a mention of jafar supporting this stance. The story of asma bint marwan is of acute embarrassment to apologists. Her crime was that she spoke out against muhammad for having another man murdered named abu afak. Apr 04, 2015 it is alleged that asma bint marwan was assassinated by prophet mohammad p because she insulted and wrote poetry against him. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. She was a poetess and a mother for whose death our prophetsaw is being held responsible. Part 1 story of asma bint marwans killing true or false. April 4, 2015 what the apologists want you to believe the story of asma bint marwan is of acute embarrassment to apologists. Nov 17, 2016 story of asma bint marwans killing true or false. His book is based on oral traditions that are often discounted. Asmaa bint abu bakr companion of the prophet islamic. Interviewed about his book, the truth about muhammad. The story of the killing of asma bint marwan is mentioned by ibn sad in kitab attabaqat alkabir3 and by the author of kinzulummal under number 441 who. Pamela geller, asma bint marwan, and america gates of vienna.
Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading from here to coocoocachoo the search for yaser abdel said book 6. One theory states that asma bint umais had actually immigrated with her husband to abyssinia, but repeatedly returned to mecca and medina. Bint marwan was known for ridiculing the people of medina for obeying a chief not of their own kind. His mother was asma bint umays, who was a widow of jafar ibn abi talib prior to her second marriage with abu bakr. Asma, daughter of marwan was a female arab poet who lived in medina in 7thcentury arabia.
According to the biography of muhammad by ibn ishaq on p 675676, asma bint marwan bint means daughter so in the text she is indicated as d. However, when khalid bin walid crushed the movements around sajah, she converted to islam. Abd alaziz was also married to hafsa, a daughter of asma bint abd alrahman ibn alharith of the prominent qurayshite clan of banu makhzum. After the muslim victory over the quraysh in mecca in 624 in the battle of badr a number of muhammads opponents were killed after surrendering. Ibn sa ds kitab altabaqat alkabir describes the death of asma bint marwan. Truth about prophet ordering death of asma bint marwan islam. Then occurred the sariyyah of umayr ibn adi ibn kharashah alkhatmi against asma bint marwan, of banu umayyah ibn zayd, when five nights had remained from the month of ramadan, in the beginning of the nineteenth month from the hijrah of the apostle of allah. Muhammad didnt like people to mock or satirize him and had several persons killed for it. She was among the early converts to makkah and being the daughter of the great companion abu bakr, she was brought up in an atmosphere of purity and devotion and shared close ties with the prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. The story has been reported by some biographers on the prophets life, who collected stories without verifying if the story is true or false, hundreds of years after the prophets demise. From bilal to sumayya, the history of islam is replete with sacrifices rendered by the companions of the prophet may allahs peace and blessings be upon him. The story of the killing of asma bint marwaan is false. Part 1 story of asma bint marwan s killing true or false.
1556 912 818 970 1264 1046 1202 926 702 568 1519 272 354 1301 868 467 675 543 1136 17 976 287 593 1644 791 1526 709 973 713 1070 132 1347 1485 252 278 724 656 1350 283 1130 728 742